Gilberto was sent off after receiving two particularly harsh yellow cards as Arsenal lost 1-0 to Newcastle at St James Park.
Alan Shearer committed numerous fouls, which given the context of Gilberto's sending off were at the very least the equivalent off two yellow cards, which would have culminated in Shearer's dismissal. Shearer was only given a 'cosmetic' booking for kicking the ball away in the 90th minute.
This simply didn't happen as Dermot Gallagher got caught up in the atmosphere by giving the home side the benefit of the doubt on far too many occasions and produced a performance as poor and inconsistent as Arsenal own away form.
This aside it was a decent first half display from Arsenal, as they dominated and the returning Alexander Hleb caused problems for Newcastle with his free, determined running and well timed, neat and creative passing. Arsenal were the better side for the majority of the first half and Henry should have scored form Fabregas' pass but was unlucky to see Given produced an excellent save and divert it behind.
Then 10 minutes after the break Gilberto received a second booking for an honest and innocuous challenge and Arsenal were down to 10 men.
The game can change one of two ways if there is a seemingly unjust sending off.
It can go the way it did against Newcastle on Saturday, with the numerical disadvantage exposing physical weakness and ultimately sapping the energy and creative drive out of the team, which is a sign of low confidence and lack of resilience.
The game can also go a different way, like it did away to Liverpool in 2001/2, when Gio Van Bronkhorst was sent of for a phantom dive. Or Monaco did against Chelsea in the Champions League. It can inspire teams and make them more resilient and ruthless than before, more determined and confident that they go harder into the challenges and play with a channeled aggression.
Arsenal, at the moment, don't have that ability and I wasn't surprised to see us roll over.
The referee was abysmal. Agreed. However, Arsenal have big problems which were exposed again.
Gilberto and Fabregas is not a viable option in away games, as I said in my last post, Gilberto needs a minder.. He is NOT an enforcer..
Fabregas is an immense talent but his fantastic technical ability cannot make up for Gilberto's shortcomings. Nor should it have to, he is 18. HE should be the one protected, the kid is still growing.
To bring the best out of a midfield which looks woefully short and a shadow of the midfield that went unbeaten, Arsenal need a physical presence, a true enforcer, to add the drive back into the team.
Pires and Ljungberg is no longer as effective as they don't have the confidence to drive forward as often. Reyes works hard and is still learning, but he is not the player we all hoped he would be at this stage. Hleb looks class. He is important in helping us limit the damage.
Sides have taken Bolton's stance and believe that for the first time in a long time that Arsenal are vulnerable and can be out muscled, outfought and ultimately are there for the taking. If you are up for it against Arsenal, you have more than half a chance.
As is well documented, Vieira is missed. He had the trust of his team mates, was close to many of them, he had a telepathic link to Bergkamp, Henry would run for him, which added an essential dynamic aspect to the side, he would cover for Pires' defensive frailties and gelled the team together, on top of having the ability to drive the team on and the respect of everyone who loves the club.
Arsene has ripped out a central cog and not replaced it. It is time to do just that.